10 Legit Reasons You Should NOT Rock Climb

Climbing keeps blowing up. It is in the Olympics now, gyms keep popping up, and odds are someone in your life is already trying to drag you to one. So before you buy shoes and start chalking up, here are 10 legit reasons you should not rock climb, or at least a few things worth knowing so you can make the right call for you.

Let me be clear up front. I am not saying climbing is bad. I love it and I plan to do it for the rest of my life (ideally still pulling on plastic when I can barely walk, because that is how it works, right?). But climbing is not for everyone, and there are some real downsides you should weigh before you go all in.

These are actual disadvantages of climbing, not the fake ones you see on most lists that dress up good things as reasons to stay away. So here are 10 things to think about before you tie in for the first time.

The 10 legit reasons you should not rock climb

Read them, laugh at a couple, and then go climb anyway. Or don’t. That part is on you.

1. Rock climbing is dangerous

Most climbers pick up some kind of injury eventually, minor or major. People do die climbing, usually from bad equipment use or trusting the wrong belayer. According to this study on climbing-related injuries, fewer than 1% of climbers die from it. Most injuries are the small stuff, torn skin, cranky tendons, that kind of thing, and they heal. But like any sport, if you don’t want to get hurt, don’t do it. A lot of the danger comes down to skipping the basics, which is why it is worth reading up on the common mistakes beginners make before you ever leave the ground.

I watched my now wife fall 60 feet because of an equipment error. She spent weeks in the ICU, went to rehab to relearn how to walk, and it took years before she could run again, so I know first-hand how bad it can get. If you do start climbing, take a course on belaying, anchor building, all of it. That knowledge is what keeps a fun day from turning into a hospital visit.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Climb Butter (@climbutter) on Dec 20, 2019 at 7:16pm PST

2. Rough hands

Climbing gives you calluses, so say goodbye to soft hands. Controlled calluses are actually a good thing because they let you grip rock and pull hard without tearing skin, so if you want to climb well, you need them. My wife and I both climb (yes, even after the 60 foot fall) and we both have rough, callused hands. We made our peace with it, but it does make hand holding and backrubs a little less romantic.

3. The climber hunch

Climbers tend to get a hunched back, and it is not a great look. Climbing hammers your front shoulders and chest and mostly ignores your back, so imbalances creep in and your shoulders round forward to protect your rotator cuffs. Most people don’t know this starting out, so they get the hunch before they know to fight it. Good news is it is fixable. Train your back, balance things out, and you end up with solid posture instead. Just know it means adding some off-the-wall work to your routine.

4. Climbing shoes hurt

Climbing shoes hurt, and they never really get comfy. Compared to sneakers, they leave no room for your toes to spread out, and your toes end up jammed against the front of the shoe. That can be uncomfortable and sometimes flat out painful. The tightness is on purpose though. You want your toes close to the rock so you can stand on tiny edges, and any wiggle room makes you more likely to slip. If you need comfort while you exercise, climbing shoes are going to be a hard sell, and climbing without them is brutal. If you want to take some of the sting out, here is why some people wear socks with climbing shoes.

5. Climbing clothes get wrecked and pricey

Anything you wear to climb is going to get trashed, or at least so caked in chalk that you have to wash it constantly, which wears it out faster. Climb outside and you will snag your shirt on a branch or tear your shorts on a slip sooner or later. Hiking and climbing clothes hold up better, so you can buy those instead, but they cost more and the style options are thinner.

6. You can’t just climb alone

For roped climbing you need a belay partner, so you are always depending on someone else to get out. There are groups and apps for finding partners, but on top of building trust with them, you have to line up your schedule with theirs and hope they don’t bail last minute. If you are trying to get more people into the sport so you always have a partner, we wrote a whole guide on how to introduce your friends to climbing.

7. Climbing can be really frustrating

Climbing is hard and it can drive you nuts. It takes strength, sure, but also flexibility and a lot of problem solving, so being a beginner can feel humbling in a hurry. Nothing quite like grinding on a climb for a week, convinced it is impossible, and then watching a kid half your size float up it like it is nothing. That happened to me today, actually.

8. Fear of falling is real

Falling is not only an injury risk, it is a mental wall too, and for some people it is a big one. Your odds of falling a real distance are way higher in climbing than in most sports, so if heights or falling scare you, this is going to be a tough one to get into. I have a climbing friend who has fought a fear of falling for years, and it still gets to him. Some days he has to lower off and go home to reset. It is not a factor for everyone, but it is a common one, and it is a big part of why so many people call this such a mental sport.

9. Climbing culture

Climbing comes with a culture of tree rock hugging nature lovers you may or may not want to hang with. Climbers tend to care a lot about the environment, so you might get pulled into recycling and keeping the wild parts wild (untouched by industry, not by hands, because climbers love getting their hands all over those mountains). That is not really a problem, but if you don’t love being judged, keep it in mind. I have shown up to the gym with a disposable bottle and felt the side-eye. If getting judged bugs you, that is worth a thought.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Sara.G.French (@climbing.love__) on Dec 18, 2019 at 2:41am PST

10. Gear costs money and needs upkeep

Buying and maintaining gear is a real chunk of time and cash. For indoor climbing you either rent a harness, carabiner, and belay device, or you buy your own. There are starter kits that bundle all of that at a discount. Head outdoors and you will need rope and quickdraws on top of that, plus a first-aid kit (better safe than sorry).

On top of buying it, you have to keep it clean and stop it from getting beat up in transport so it stays dependable. Unlike a lot of sports, you can’t really buy climbing gear second-hand. Your life rides on the safety stuff, and there is no reliable way to know old gear is still up to standard, so you buy it new. If you want it to last, it also helps to have a smart way to store it, and we rounded up storage ideas for your climbing gear for exactly that.

So should you climb anyway?

I hope that after all that, you still give climbing a shot. The list looks discouraging, but the upside blows every one of these out of the water. I have lived through every single item here, right down to watching my wife fall 60 feet in front of me, so I am not sugarcoating the risks. And even so, nothing else gives me the physical, mental, and emotional payoff that climbing does. It is one of my favorite things in the world, and the peace and satisfaction I get from it is something I hope you get to feel too.

If you do decide to give it a go, the smartest thing you can do early is get a little better every week instead of trying to fix everything at once. That is exactly what our free newsletter is for. We send one short climbing drill a week, about 15 minutes each, so you build real skill without overthinking it. Grab the free 15-minute training newsletter here and start stacking small wins.

Frequently asked questions

Are these really legit reasons you should not rock climb?

They are real downsides, but most of them are things you can manage or even fix. Danger drops when you take a belay and anchor course, the climber hunch is correctable with back work, and gear costs come down with starter kits. They are honest trade-offs, not deal-breakers for most people.

Is rock climbing actually that dangerous?

Most injuries are minor, like torn skin and overused tendons, and fewer than 1% of climbers die from it according to the study linked above. The serious accidents usually trace back to equipment misuse or a bad belay, which is why learning the safety basics matters so much.

Can you rock climb alone?

Roped climbing needs a belay partner, so you can’t really do that solo. Bouldering is the exception since it is done on shorter walls with pads instead of ropes, but even then a spotter and a buddy are safer than going it alone.

Do climbing shoes ever stop hurting?

They break in a little and get less painful, but they are meant to fit snug so your toes sit close to the rock. If you want to take the edge off, sizing up slightly for longer sessions and wearing thin socks can both help.

Is climbing worth starting despite the downsides?

For most people, yes. The physical, mental, and emotional benefits tend to outweigh the drawbacks, and nearly every downside on this list can be reduced with good habits and a little know-how. Start slow, learn the basics, and build up one week at a time.

Sara Climbing Coach, Climbing Trainer, Writer

Sara is the founder of Send Edition, author of '77 Drills to Help You Climb Better,' the creator of 'Elevate Your Climbing: Training Planner and Tracker,' and climbing coach.

See Full Bio

Climbing Training